The First Independent Analysis of a Pork Pie for the Pork Pie Appreciation Society   




Artisan Class


1st Honley Village  Butchers – pork, chorizo, goats cheese & sweet chilli sauce 
2nd Keith Dyson – full English breakfast
3rd Honley Village Butchers – pork, chicken & stuffing
4th J. Thomas of Helmsley 
5th E. Middlemiss – pork, stuffing & Yorkshire chutney


Traditional Class


1st Hoffman’s of Wakefield 
2nd Wilson’s of Crossgates, Leeds 
3rd Broster’s of Lindley, Huddersfield.
4th Honley Village Butchers, Huddersfield.


The First Independent Analysis of a Pork Pie for the Pork Pie Appreciation Society PDF Print E-mail
Pork Pie Report 2010

Mike and Colby’s Independent PP report for PPAP Producer: Bradley’s Bakery, reputedly (own assessment) best pork pie, Ashton-under-Lyne (

Subjects: Two standard and one 1arge stand pie, purchased warm. One standard eaten in the field, others returned to base for detailed assessment/examination.

Pork PiesExternal appearance: Pale and slightly bulbous, not well glazed, hole for gravy.

Cross-section: Meat pink and well-textured – granular and friable, gravy not full to hole but some present in pie. Pastry for lid and sides thick and was quite crumbly – evidence of pastry trimming re-use: multilayering in lid.

Taste: Meat up there with the best peppery, good porky taste and nice texture. Gravy only added for moistness sake no flavour at all (sampled separately in polystyrene cup for top up purposes). Probably meat taste is the reason for local claims to greatness, plus lack of competition this side of the Yorkshire border.

Pastry while quite tasty, was ultimately disappointing: too thick, very hard in parts, undercooked and doughy others consistency was not good needed more fat content, tended towards short crust crumble rather than hot water ‘snap’.

Summary: a good tasting pie but plenty of room for improvement particularly in the pastry more fat here please and thinner. The lack of flavour in the gravy was also a missed opportunity.

Overall score: Appearance: 6/10, flavour: 8/10 for meat, 2/10 for gravy, 4/10 pastry, general: 6/10 Grand score overall: 52% (certainly not


Pie Club Images


Who's Online

We have 23 guests online

Please Login

  Copyright © 2003 - 2018 Pork Pie Appreciation Society. All Rights Reserved.  
Design by and